Jump to content

  • Log in with Facebook      Sign In   
  • Create Account       

Photo

When should you start calorie restriction?

age

  • Please log in to reply
9 replies to this topic

#1 qwntia

qwntia
  • Member
  • 5 posts

Posted 09 May 2018 - 09:44 AM

This says:

children, adolescents, and young adults (under approx 21) should be advised against starting CR. Physical growth may be impaired by calorie restriction, as observed in lab animals. In addition, mental development and physical changes to the brain take place in late adolescence and early adulthood that could be negatively affected by calorie restriction. For this group, the best advice is to follow a normal (non-CR) diet until reaching early twenties.

However, according to this, brain development continues "well into our 20s" (i.e. beyond approx 21). I am wondering if starting CR in one's early or mid 20s would impair brain development. I recall reading that CR can also slow brain deterioration, though, so it might be the case that starting CR in one's early or mid 20s would still be a net positive for brain functioning in the long term.

 

Any relevant insights would be appreciated.



#2 Gordo

Gordo
  • Member
  • 565 posts
  • Website URL:http://gordosoft.com

Posted 09 May 2018 - 01:31 PM

First you have to define CR before anyone can comment on how beneficial it may be or what age to start. 



#3 qwntia

qwntia
  • Member
  • 5 posts

Posted 10 May 2018 - 06:34 AM

First you have to define CR before anyone can comment on how beneficial it may be or what age to start. 

By CR I mean calorie restriction, of course. What else did you want specified?



#4 Gordo

Gordo
  • Member
  • 565 posts
  • Website URL:http://gordosoft.com

Posted 10 May 2018 - 08:21 AM

 

First you have to define CR before anyone can comment on how beneficial it may be or what age to start. 

By CR I mean calorie restriction, of course. What else did you want specified?

 

For instance, I consider myself "doing CR" because I eat fewer calories than I did when I was true "ad lib" feeding, and fewer calories than an average American of my height and gender.  Others here seem to have different criteria.  At any rate, serious calorie restriction will impact both physical and mental growth and development.  Some would argue that this is the goal, so what's the problem?  On the other hand if your idea of CR just means eating lots of fruits and veges and not allowing yourself to be overweight, then you are golden.


Edited by Gordo, 10 May 2018 - 10:41 AM.


#5 mccoy

mccoy
  • Member
  • 1,183 posts

Posted 10 May 2018 - 10:10 AM

CR is actually not very easy to define. I prefer Michael Rae's definition since it provides an objective benchmark, that is, one's weight in one's late twenties, to be decreased by at least 15%.

 

I cannot answer the question but I would wait, as a precautionary measure, for my thirties, in the meanwhile being happy to practice a CR mimicking regime like gordo describes, based on healthy, hormetic plant-based food.

 

As a very personal and debatable opinion, I believe that CR as above defined is very good for overweight persons, with a metabolism which favours fat accumulation, whereas its benefits may be dubious for naturally lean people.


"Data speak for themselves" -Reverend Thomas Bayes 1702-1761
P(Ai|E)=(P(E|Ai)P(Ai))/P(E)


#6 Matt

Matt
  • Member
  • 95 posts
  • Website URL:http://www.crvitality.com

Posted 10 May 2018 - 12:27 PM

I started decreasing my weight when I was 18 years old, but at certain points in my life, I was quite skinny from all the exercise and not eating much. And giving my dog the food under the table (especially meat, which I hated).

 

I don't think my brain is underdeveloped. Although, I am prone to a few typos here and there, so who knows? :p

 

Seriously though, I have pretty good self-control, and I'm not exactly dumb, and generally emotionally stable and rational. My brain seems to have developed fine. I'm not exactly a genius either though! My strengths are more in communication and language than math.

I think the environment and home you grow up in is going to have a much bigger impact on your brain development than eating fewer calories. 

 

My BMI from age 20 to 26? was around BMI 16.3

 

I wouldn't personally drop that low again though. In fact, I can eat fewer calories now than when I was 20 and I maintain a higher weight. Feels like my metabolism has slowed a lot.


Edited by Matt, 10 May 2018 - 12:29 PM.


#7 qwntia

qwntia
  • Member
  • 5 posts

Posted 11 May 2018 - 06:38 AM

 

 

First you have to define CR before anyone can comment on how beneficial it may be or what age to start. 

By CR I mean calorie restriction, of course. What else did you want specified?

 

For instance, I consider myself "doing CR" because I eat fewer calories than I did when I was true "ad lib" feeding, and fewer calories than an average American of my height and gender.  Others here seem to have different criteria.  At any rate, serious calorie restriction will impact both physical and mental growth and development.  Some would argue that this is the goal, so what's the problem?  On the other hand if your idea of CR just means eating lots of fruits and veges and not allowing yourself to be overweight, then you are golden.

 

Thank you for the explanation. Do you know of any resources to help estimate the minimum amount of calories needed to avoid inhibiting brain development for someone whose brain is not yet fully developed? I know one is considered underweight if one's BMI is less than 18.5, so I was wondering if restricting caloric intake would be okay if BMI is kept above that.



#8 qwntia

qwntia
  • Member
  • 5 posts

Posted 11 May 2018 - 07:42 AM

I started decreasing my weight when I was 18 years old, but at certain points in my life, I was quite skinny from all the exercise and not eating much. And giving my dog the food under the table (especially meat, which I hated).

 

I don't think my brain is underdeveloped. Although, I am prone to a few typos here and there, so who knows? :p

 

Seriously though, I have pretty good self-control, and I'm not exactly dumb, and generally emotionally stable and rational. My brain seems to have developed fine. I'm not exactly a genius either though! My strengths are more in communication and language than math.

I think the environment and home you grow up in is going to have a much bigger impact on your brain development than eating fewer calories. 

 

My BMI from age 20 to 26? was around BMI 16.3

 

I wouldn't personally drop that low again though. In fact, I can eat fewer calories now than when I was 20 and I maintain a higher weight. Feels like my metabolism has slowed a lot.

Thanks for the input. That said, since your experience is a case study and since it's hard to determine what your intelligence would have been if you kept a higher BMI (because there's no control group), the evidence your experience provides is extremely weak. It does provide significant evidence that starting CR when ~18 doesn't have a massive effect on intelligence, but I wouldn't have thought there was one, a priori, considering brain already undergo a lot of development before the age of 18 (18-year-olds aren't that dumb, after all).



#9 Matt

Matt
  • Member
  • 95 posts
  • Website URL:http://www.crvitality.com

Posted 11 May 2018 - 08:54 AM

I was thinking more about your question earlier. The prefrontal lobe continues to develop throughout our 20s, and expect if anything, CR may impact this development. Although I am not a neurobiologist and haven't really studied this area either.

 

But things like risk-taking, impulsivity, addiction and those sorts of things could be greater if this part of the brain were underdeveloped due to caloric restriction. I can only provide my anecdotal story, but I am none of those. I'm far from impulsive, I've never had any addiction problems, and I'm not exactly a big risk-taker (especially if compared to male population).

 

When I look back, I don't think I was dumb at 18, but most of my education came after I left high school. 

 

But yeah, *weak* evidence.

 

All that being said, if you're a Lemur, apparently CR does have an effect on the brain  

 

This kind of thing hasn't really been studied in people who've done CRON from a young age. There is probably some data from girls with eating disorders and brain development and impoverished populations, but that's not exactly the kind of information we can use either.

I don't know what reasoning is being *21* for starting CR. Perhaps CRSociety is just being cautious, or maybe there is good reasoning for it. Also, how many extra good years (assuming CR translates well to humans) could you get from waiting until your late 20s anyway?
 

I think it would be harder to tweak metabolism and optimize the system in your 20s (to slow aging) than it would be if you are over 30. 

 

Well, I'm very happy I started when I did. No regrets. But I'm just one little case. :)


Edited by Matt, 11 May 2018 - 09:05 AM.


#10 qwntia

qwntia
  • Member
  • 5 posts

Posted 12 May 2018 - 06:23 AM

I was thinking more about your question earlier. The prefrontal lobe continues to develop throughout our 20s, and expect if anything, CR may impact this development. Although I am not a neurobiologist and haven't really studied this area either.

According to this, eating disorders can indeed cause brain damage. Of course, this doesn't mean CR does due to CR practitioners having good nutrition and perhaps less extreme restriction of calories. (I take it when you say prefrontal lobe you mean prefrontal cortex.)

 

I think it would be harder to tweak metabolism and optimize the system in your 20s (to slow aging) than it would be if you are over 30.

Interesting. What is your evidence for this?







Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: age